Key Takeaways
Even when choosing the most environmentally friendly dental products, there will come a stage when you are finished with it.
You are then left wondering what to do with the waste.
Manual toothbrushes are difficult to recycle.
At present, there isn’t such a thing as a 100% natural or plastic free toothbrush that has no impact on the planet.
So you will need to recycle the toothbrush correctly to ensure minimal impact on the environment.
For a small number of toothbrushes, they may be recyclable at home once bristles have been removed. The most important thing is to carefully look at the material of the handle.
The toothbrush head with bristles need to be recycled in specialist schemes, whether that is through TerraCycle or manufacturer return schemes.
The same goes for other dental products such as toothpaste packaging and flossing tools.
Read on to find out what to do with them when they can no longer be used for oral healthcare.
Toothbrushes as they are can’t go in your normal recycling
Toothbrushes as they are cannot go in with normal household plastic recycling.
One problem is the nylon bristles, which are not recycled by local facilities.
Nylon in toothbrush bristles needs to be sent to specialist recovery programmes.
Take the bristles off the brush, and you are just left with the handle to recycle.
Traditional handles often have more than one material which cannot be separated at normal recycling facilities. This makes those sorts of handles non recyclable.
However, it is possible that some handles with the bristles removed could be added to household recycling.
For example, TePe states that its Polypropylene and Polyethylene handles can be recycled with household recycling (after the bristles are removed).
The biggest difficulty is getting a firm answer from a toothbrush manufacturer about what material the handle actually is.
Use these guidelines to determine if your brush handle can go in the recycling
The following guidelines should be checked with your local recycling provider as rules do vary from one place to the next.
These are recommendations for handles where the bristles have been removed.
- Bamboo handles: can go in with garden waste, on a home composting pile, or with industrial composting.
- Single plastic handles: can go in with plastic recycling (if accepted by local systems).
- Bio-based plastic handles: can go in plastic recycling or industrial composting, depending on the material.
There is no dentistry specific guidance as yet.
I have looked to the United States Environmental Protection Agency but you do need to check your own local recycling information for advice on exactly which type of plastics are accepted.
This Which article explains which types of plastics are normally accepted by recycling facilities (the article is UK based but gives good examples of different types of plastics).
The Less Waste website also explains the different recycling options for plastics well.
Wherever possible, when reviewing toothbrushes for our eco-friendly toothbrush roundup, I have put information about the type of plastic it is.
The table below lists the recycling options that are available for different handle types.
| Handle Material | Recycling Options |
|---|---|
| Bamboo handles | Home composting Industrial composting Garden waste recycling Specialist toothbrush recycling |
| Bio-based plastic handles | Plastic recycling collections (sometimes) Specialist toothbrush recycling (sometimes) |
| “Compostable” or “biodegradable” plastic handles | Home composting (sometimes) Industrial composting (sometimes) Do not place with plastic recycling |
| Recycled plastic handles number 5 (PP) | Normally can go with plastic recycling Specialist toothbrush recycling |
| Recycled plastic handles number 7 (other) | Rarely can go with plastic recycling, goes with household waste Specialist toothbrush recycling |
| Handles with more than one material | Household waste (not recyclable) Specialist toothbrush recycling |
Don’t assume bioplastic products can go in the recycling
The development of newer types of plastics, sometimes called bioplastic, is an area of confusion.
Factories where recycling occurs need to make sure the end product isn’t contaminated. Adding some types of bioplastic to regular plastic recycling can create problems.
Bioplastics is a word used to describe many different things. It is an overarching term that can include:
- bio-based plastics: plastics which are derived from natural/plant-based resources instead of fossil fuels. The end structure is the same, it is just a different starting block.
- biodegradable plastics : either fossil fuel derived plastics or bio-based plastics, but which biodegrade. This means they break down with the aid of microorganisms.
- compostable plastics : either fossil fuel derived plastics or bio-based plastics, but which are compostable. This means they break down, under specific conditions, into biomass, carbon dioxide and water.
Bio-based plastics have pretty much the same structure as conventional plastic. They are not automatically biodegradable or compostable, no matter what manufacturers tell you! These could go with your plastic recycling collections, once the bristles have been removed.
Obviously, not all plastics are accepted at all recycling collections.
Biodegradable and compostable plastics have a different structure and are not recyclable.
When it comes to end of life options, biodegradable plastics such as PLA cannot currently be recycled with other plastics (for example milk bottles, which are collected as part of your household collection). It can damage the recycling equipment if included incorrectly.
Don’t take a manufacturers’ word that something can be home composted
Those that have had independent testing could be added to the appropriate home or industrial composting piles. Do not just take a manufacturers’ word that something can be composted at home. Ask for evidence and testing certificates.
Yes, there is evidence to show that PLA is biodegradable, however the conditions needed means it needs industrial composting. You can’t just throw it on your home compost pile, as it will take years as a lump in the shape of a toothbrush head.
At the moment, there is a lack of these industrial composting facilities world wide.
So whilst all these companies are making “biodegradable” plastics, we just don’t have the facilities to get rid of them yet. Some food and garden waste goes to industrial composting facilities, but this varies from council to council. If you know your waste goes to such a facility, biodegradable plastics could in theory be thrown in with this waste. However at the sorting plant, it may be confused for conventional plastic and be removed anyway.
Ironically, without proper recycling facilities, these plastics may well end up with general waste. If this waste goes to landfill, the biodegradable plastics break down and release methane, a gas with a greater impact than carbon dioxide. In some respects this is worse than conventional plastics going to landfill!
The take home message is that bio-based plastics have a smaller carbon footprint. Biodegradable plastics at present pose a challenge for recycling, and their environmental impact could be even less if waste streams were changed to recycle the materials properly.
End-of-life-options for bioplastics
As mentioned above, ‘bioplastic’ is a term to describe many different things.
The diagram below shows the difference between how bio-based & durable bioplastics are dealt with at the end of their life (on the left), compared to how biodegradable & compostable bioplastics are dealt with.
How To Remove Toothbrush Bristles
There is the chance that your toothbrush handle is recyclable at home, as long as the bristles are removed.
So how do you remove toothbrush bristles?
First option is to try pulling them out with pliers, as demonstrated here.
Freezing the brush beforehand can make this easier to do.
Another option is to remove the head section of the toothbrush. If you are safely able to do so, use a small saw to cut off the head part of the toothbrush.
TerraCycle is another options for hard-to-recycle waste
TerraCycle is an innovative recycling company. It has become a global leader in managing hard-to-recycle waste.
It aims to prevent waste going to landfill by recycling it instead.
TerraCycle works with well known brands to provide free recycling programmes for oral care products and packaging.
Rather than throwing away your toothbrush and empty tube of toothpaste, you can recycle it via Terracycle.
TerraCycle rewards collectors with donations to schools, charities and non profit organisations.
By partaking in the scheme, not only does the environment win, but local communities benefit too.
TerraCycle systems in Canada
There are three TerraCycle schemes you can use in Canada to recycle your toothbrush and other dental care products.
Two are free to use (Tom’s of Maine and P & G), and one involves paying for your own box.
The three schemes accept slightly different products:
Proctor & Gamble (P&G) Oral Care Recycling Program. This scheme is sponsored by P & G, the makers behind Crest and Oral-B. It is free to use. You simply drop off your items at the relevant public drop-off location. The scheme is brand new and at the time of writing didn’t have any drop-off points, but go back to the Terracycle site regularly to see if this changes. Alternatively, you could join the program and add your own drop-off location. Only some products are accepted, but they can be from any brand. The person hosting the box collects points for products sent in to TerraCycle, and then uses these points to donate money to their chosen cause.
Tom’s of Maine and hello Natural Care Recycling Program. Tom’s of Maine and hello Natural Care sponsor this scheme. It provides free public drop-off locations (find a map of them here). The scheme accepts products from any brand. The person hosting the box collects points for products sent in to TerraCycle, and then uses these points to donate money to their chosen cause.
Oral Care Waste and Packaging – Zero Waste Box™. This box is not free. It is one that you would need to pay for (prices start at $138.00). It does accept a wide variety of dental care products. You order and pay for the box, which is then returned to TerraCycle when full. You do not earn points for these boxes. Accepted dental products could also be added to the No Separation – Zero Waste Box™ (from $227.00, but accepts a wider range of products).
How TerraCycle works
You take your used manual toothbrush and other dental products to the recycling point.
That location has joined the TerraCycle scheme. They collect from multiple people. They box it all up and label it.
The collected items are then sent to a TerraCycle sorting facility in the country where the waste was collected.
Once at the TerraCycle facility, they collect, weigh, and check the shipment for contamination.
TerraCycle explains their processes on its website.
The materials are sent to appropriate factories and used to produce useful recycled materials.
Firstly, the recyclable products are separated depending on the material.
Paper and cardboard fibres are hydropulped to separate out coatings (like wax and plastics) and then recycled into new paper products. They are composted if recycling is not possible.
Plastics will be recycled into plastic polymers.
The materials are then shredded, washed.
The plastics are melted into hard plastic pellets.
From there, companies can buy the plastic pellets. These plastic pellets can be used to make new recycled products such as benches.
TerraCycle does not pay the collectors for the boxes of oral care products that it collects.
But it does offer a rewards programme.
TerraCycle rewards shipments based on their weight. The rewards are called TerraCycle Points.
For Tom’s Of Maine collections Shipments in this program must be at least 2 pounds to earn points. Each shipment earns 100 points per pound. This equates to individual piece earning approximately 4.3 TerraCycle points based on an average unit weight of 19.5 grams.
For shipments in the P & G Oral Care Recycling Program, packages do not need to be a minimum weight to earn TerraCycle points. Each used or empty oral care item sent in will earn approximately 2 TerraCycle points. It works out that about 100 points per pound will be awarded.
TerraCycle points can be redeemed for a variety of charitable gifts or a payment of $0.01 per point to the non-profit organization or school of your choice.
To redeem the points as financial donations, a minimum of 1000 points or $10 is required.
Anyone can sign up to the P & G and Tom’s of Maine programmes as a private collector or a public location which will be visible on the relevant TerraCycle map.
What is and isn’t accepted by each programme
The exact products accepted will depend on the specific box. See the table below for a full guide to what is and isn’t collected in the different TerraCycle boxes.
In order to recycle the products properly, TerraCycle asks that you remove all the excess product (i.e. leftover toothpaste).
You do not necessarily have to rinse the product. But if you do choose to rinse it, it must be completely dry before placing it in the recycling bin.
| What Is Accepted | What Is Not Accepted | |
|---|---|---|
| P & G Oral Care Recycling | Non-electric toothbrushes, toothpaste tubes and caps, toothpaste cartons, toothpaste outer packaging, floss containers, all other non-recyclable products and packaging | Battery operated toothbrushes, Electric toothbrush handles, Batteries |
| Tom’s Of Maine & hello Natural Care Recycling | Mouthwash bottles and caps, Toothbrushes, Deodorant containers and caps, Soap packaging, Floss containers, Toothpaste tubes and caps | Battery operated toothbrushes, Electric toothbrush handles, Dental floss, Batteries |
| Oral Care Waste and Packaging – Zero Waste Box™ | Toothpaste tubes and caps, Toothbrushes, toothbrush and toothpaste tube outer packaging, floss containers. | Battery operated toothbrushes, Electric toothbrush handles, Dental floss, Batteries |
Criticism of TerraCycle
TerraCycle may seem like the perfect solution for your dental waste. But I think there are some things to consider when using the schemes.
Dental care is a plastic intensive industry. For some items, yes, single use plastic is unavoidable.
But there are many areas where improvements could be made to make more environmentally friendly products.
It reduces pressure on manufacturers
Using TerraCycle could be seen as a buy out and stops pressure on manufacturers to actually change their products.
There are some types of material that TerraCycle does not accept. It does not accept bamboo and bio-based plastics, for example.
The problem is that these are seen as environmentally friendly alternative materials. The problem is, they are only a better alternative if they can be disposed of properly when you are no longer using them.
TerraCycle doesn’t accept them, and neither do most kerbside collections. With manufacturers moving towards bio-based plastic alternatives to traditional plastic, this leaves few options for recycling when finished with the product.
It reduces personal incentive to change
Another downside of using recycling through TerraCycle is that it provides less incentive to swap to options which have less of an impact on the environment.
This applies on an individual level — why choose the more expensive compostable option when you can have the disposable plastic option which is recycled by TerraCycle?!
This perceived guilt free option doesn’t push individuals towards ethical consumerism (making spending choices on more ethical products).
Without drive from individuals, we are also not pushing the big companies into developing new technologies.
It reduces incentive for companies to change their products and packaging
Large companies that sponsor TerraCycle boxes get a tick in the box for environmentalism, but in some cases they aren’t actually doing anything to change the systems they have produced.
There is no incentive for these companies to change packaging to be easy to recycle if TerraCycle will accept their current products.
These large companies are getting lots of publicity as being more environmentally friendly when they are doing very little to change their impact on the environment. This is classic greenwashing.
That said, at least large companies throwing cash at the problem does provide free recycling. The boxes are otherwise really quite expensive to buy personally, much outside of the price range for an average family.
Some regard this system as greenwashing
TerraCycle is a profitable company. We live in a capitalist society. Some people make calls that the company is greenwashing and that they are “fake environmentalists” because of this.
Personally I think there is a balance to be had between making a profit and making something affordable for the general public.
TerraCycle is a good option for when there truly is no other alternative for recycling (e.g. items that aren’t accepted kerbside). And for items where there is currently no other less impactful material (toothbrush bristles, for which there is currently no plastic free option).
Upcycling projects are a good way to re-use products
When it comes to minimising your effect on the environments, think about the three Rs:
- Reduce
- Reuse
- Recycle
Even though you shouldn’t be using your toothbrush to brush your teeth after about 3 months, your toothbrush still has plenty of life in it.
From cleaning difficult to reach places, to painting, to craft projects, your toothbrush can be used for plenty of other things before you recycle it.
Eco Green Love has lots of helpful hints and tips for how to upcycle your toothbrush.
Can you make more environmentally friendly product choices?
When it comes to choosing more environmentally friendly products, there is no absolute right or wrong answer.
Neither dentistry nor sustainability is “a one recommendation fits all” topic. There are many complicating factors that make one choice the best for one person, but not for another.
The most important thing is to choose a brush with a lower impact, that you find comfortable to use, and to make sure you are using it properly.
In many cases, manual toothbrushes have less impact on the environment than an electric toothbrush.
It is certainly more eco-friendly for someone at low risk of dental problems.
But if you are at high risk of gum disease or tooth decay, then effective cleaning needs to be the number one priority. Prioritising your health is more important than absolute zero waste. And this normally comes from using an electric toothbrush.
Preventing diseases so that you do not need dental treatment is the best way to reduce your impact on the environment, because dental treatments generate large amounts of waste.
We have another page that discusses the most eco-friendly manual toothbrushes.
Be aware that whilst bamboo may seem an obvious choice, recycled plastic may actually have less of an impact, so long as it can be easily recycled. This is dependent on what recycling facilities you have available.
Thinking about what recycling options you have available to you should be a consideration when choosing what toothbrush is more environmentally friendly for you to use.
For example, bamboo is a poor choice if you don’t have the ability to compost it when you are finished.
Some plastic handles can actually go in with normal recycling, once you have removed the bristles.
Use your spending power to make better choices for the environment. This ethical consumerism will drive the market to change.
